Stop Aging Up YA Characters. It’s Ruining the Genre.

Teens deserve books written for them.

It often starts with a small shift that doesn’t seem like it should matter.

A character is aged up slightly. The tone becomes a little older. The situations become a little more adult.

On paper, these changes might feel minor, but in Young Adult fiction, these small shifts can have a significant impact on who a story is actually for. When the emotional perspective, content, or character experiences drift too far from adolescence, the category itself can begin to lose the intended audience.

For example, this past year I read a book that was marketed as YA. It had a twenty-year-old protagonist, language and content that was geared much older, and a voice and style that felt more fitting as a NA than YA. And while the story was definitely entertaining, it felt like it was written for adult readers of YA, not the actual target age.

This isn’t about restricting storytelling or limiting what writers can explore. It’s about remembering what YA is designed to do and who it is for. The more time I spend reading and writing YA, the clearer this becomes: Aging up YA characters, doesn’t just change the story it loses the intended audience.

YA Is Meant for Teen Readers

Young Adult is not simply a marketing label. It represents a specific stage of life.

It’s about the years where everything feels like too much. First love feels all-consuming. Mistakes feel apocalyptic. You’re desperate for independence but still deeply tethered to your parents and school. I remember that age, (and I bet you do, too) because you feel EVERYTHING so intensely. Perhaps more than any other season of your life.

It’s beautiful. And it’s painful. And it’s worth celebrating.

YA stories traditionally center on characters navigating the transition from childhood to adulthood. These are the years when identity is forming, independence is emerging, and emotions often feel larger than life. Friendships, family expectations, first relationships, and personal values are all being defined in real time.

Because of that, YA tends to be written with teen readers in mind: readers who are still living through those experiences rather than looking back on them.

When stories begin to reflect a worldview that feels distinctly adult, whether through character age, life circumstances, or narrative voice, the connection to that teen perspective weakens.

Age Alone Doesn’t Define the Category

A character’s age is often treated as the primary marker of YA, but age alone doesn’t determine whether a story truly fits the category.

Voice, emotional perspective, and the nature of the conflicts all play a role. A story with a teenage protagonist can still feel adult if the themes, situations, or tone are aimed primarily at an older audience. However, stories that remain grounded in the emotional reality of adolescence tend to resonate strongly with teen readers, even when they tackle difficult topics.

The key difference isn’t whether a story includes challenging material. YA has always explored serious issues. The difference lies in how those issues are framed and whether the narrative remains anchored in a teenage point of view.

Difficult Topics Have Always Existed in YA

Young Adult literature has never been limited to light or simple storytelling.

Many widely respected YA novels explore subjects such as mental health, identity, grief, discrimination, trauma, addiction, and systemic injustice. These themes are not new to the genre, and they are often handled with depth and care.

What distinguishes YA treatment of difficult subjects is not the absence of complexity, but the way the story centers the adolescent experience. The narrative usually prioritizes emotional discovery, personal growth, and the process of understanding the world rather than presenting a fully adult perspective.

Stories can be serious, intense, and thought-provoking while remaining appropriate for the intended audience. It is possible.

Teen Readers Know When a Book Isn’t for Them

One of the most overlooked voices in this conversation is the audience itself.

Teen readers are thoughtful, observant, and capable of engaging with meaningful material. At the same time, they deserve stories that are created with them in mind.

When books marketed as YA begin to consistently reflect adult perspectives, adult life stages, or content that assumes an adult audience, a gap forms between the label and the originally intended reader.

Libraries, educators, parents, and booksellers rely on category expectations to help guide young readers toward material that aligns with their developmental stage. When those expectations become unclear, it can make the YA space more difficult for teens to navigate confidently.

If YA stops reflecting the experience of being a teenager, then who is it for?

In Our Effort to be Marketable, We’re Missing the Market

This might upset some people. (#sorrynotsorry)

One of the biggest ways to be marketable is to engage both adult and teen readers. In the biz, we call that “crossover potential”.

It’s no secret that adults read YA. (Points to self). Honestly, I think any well written book is going to be for all ages. But something has been happened these past couple years in order to achieve that coveted tag of “crossover potential”: we’ve started catering to the adult readers instead of the teen ones.

And it upsets me. It upsets me, because I had many students who want books to read, but are scared to enter the YA section of the library because they don’t know what they will find there. Everything from voice to spice level has been “leveled up” to meet the expectations or reading desires of adults.

And we’re leaving teens in the dust.

This Isn’t About Limiting Stories

To be clear: this isn’t an argument that older protagonists don’t belong. They absolutely do. Adult fiction exists for a reason. New adult, crossover fiction, and genre-blending books are thriving. I believe there are markets and spaces for all of those books and all of those readers.

And it’s not a judgment on writers who have aged characters up. Writers are free to write their stories and characters however they choose. The conversation about appropriateness in YA isn’t about shutting down creativity. It’s about being intentional with how stories are positioned and who they are written for.

It’s about remembering the tweens and teens deserve to be seen too.

And if you want help getting started with your writing?
Grab my FREE eBook: The Writing Process—it’ll walk you through the steps, the mindset, and the magic of building a writing life.

Grab my FREE eBook here!

Let YA be YA

Young Adult fiction occupies a unique and important space in literature. For many readers, these books are where they first see their emotions, struggles, and hopes reflected on the page.

Adolescence is a period of intense growth and self-discovery. Stories that honor that stage of life can offer validation, comfort, and understanding to readers who are still figuring out who they are. Protecting the integrity of the YA category helps ensure that teen readers continue to have stories that speak directly to their experiences.

Ultimately, that is what the genre was created to do.

This conversation is complicated, and I know there are exceptions, nuances, and industry realities woven through it. But I’m curious, have you ever been told to age a character up or add adult content? Did you do it? Did it change the story?

I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

And if you want to keep talking about writing, YA, querying, and the long, messy road of publishing, you can find me on Instagram where I’m usually somewhere between drafting, revising, and overthinking everything.

Read the Latest

Get the Playlist for SOMETHING BRIGHT AND BEAUTIFUL sent right to your inbox! (including the Spotify link to listen right away!)

Get the playlist!